Many New York business owners assume employment claims are a big-company problem, something for firms with an HR department, in-house counsel and dozens of employees. If your team is two or three people, that assumption feels reasonable. In a small shop, relationships are close and issues usually get settled with a conversation.
The legal reality is different. Since February 2020, the New York State Human Rights Law applies to all private employers, regardless of headcount. Before that, businesses with fewer than four employees were exempt from much of it. That threshold is gone, and a business with a single employee can now face a complaint before the state agency.
What changed for small businesses
The law didn’t just widen who is protected. It also lowered the bar for a claim. The “severe or pervasive” standard is no longer the test, and a single discriminatory or harassing incident can be enough to support a complaint. In New York City, every employer is also subject to the city’s human rights law when it comes to sexual harassment claims, no matter how many people they employ.
On top of that come obligations many owners don’t know about: every employer with at least one employee must have a written anti-harassment policy and provide annual training. This isn’t a big-company formality. It applies to the corner pizzeria the same way it applies to a chain.
A real case that shows how it unfolds
In 2024, the EEOC, the federal agency that enforces workplace anti-discrimination laws, sued KTG Hospitality, owner of Wall Street Grill in Manhattan. According to the agency, kitchen coworkers and managers subjected a pastry cook to sexual overtures, verbal abuse and unwanted physical contact. The restaurant ultimately paid $45,000 to the former employee to settle the case.
The settlement figure is only part of the story. Before suing, the EEOC tried to resolve the matter through its conciliation process, and when that didn’t work, it filed in federal court in New York. That means months of responding to an agency, gathering documents, working with attorneys and going through a court process, all while the restaurant kept operating.
Worth noting: this case was brought under federal law, which covers employers with more than 15 employees. For a smaller business, the route is state law, which can be invoked against an employer of any size, and the resources available to respond are usually far more limited.
What EPLI is and what it covers
Employment practices liability insurance, known as EPLI, is the coverage built for these situations. It responds to claims from employees, former employees and even job applicants who were never hired, for wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, retaliation and related allegations. It typically pays for defense costs as well as settlements or judgments, within the policy limit.
That last point changes the picture for a small business. Whether or not a claim has merit, defending it costs money, and the policy keeps that cost from coming straight out of the owner’s pocket or the business’s cash flow.
What to read carefully in the policy
As with most coverages, the details matter. A few are worth understanding before a claim ever shows up.
It’s a claims-made policy. Most EPLI policies only respond if the claim is made while the policy is in force, or within an extended reporting period set by the contract. It’s not enough that the incident happened while you were insured; the claim also has to be reported on time.
The retroactive date decides what’s covered. Every policy sets how far back it will look. If you switch carriers and the new retroactive date matches the start of the new policy, prior years are no longer protected. It’s an easy detail to miss right when you’re renewing or changing carriers.
Defense costs often erode the limit. On many EPLI policies, defense costs reduce the amount left for a settlement or judgment. A $1 million limit doesn’t mean $1 million is available to pay a claim if a large share went to attorneys’ fees.
Wage and hour claims need their own look. Many policies exclude them entirely or cover only defense costs, under a reduced sublimit, without paying the wages owed. Plenty of owners assume an overtime dispute falls under the policy, and that is one of the most common and most expensive assumptions.
There are other common exclusions. Claims tied to ERISA-governed benefits, COBRA and unemployment benefits are usually left out, among others. Every policy is worded differently, which is why reading the contract matters as much as the name of the coverage.
What you can do as an employer, beyond the policy
Insurance helps once a claim has arrived. What you do beforehand largely determines whether it arrives at all, and how it plays out.
- Put your anti-harassment and anti-discrimination policy in writing and give it to every employee at hire. State law requires that it be available in the employee’s primary language, which matters for Spanish-speaking teams.
- Complete the annual harassment prevention training, even with a team of one or two, and keep a record that it was done.
- Respond to every complaint right away and in writing, even if it seems minor or comes from someone you’re close to. Responding quickly counts far more than not responding.
- Don’t make decisions affecting someone who filed a complaint (schedules, shifts, termination) without getting advice first. Retaliation is a separate claim, and it can stand even if the original complaint doesn’t.
- Document important conversations with your team: warnings, changes in duties, the reasons for a termination. Keep them dated and simple.
- Keep an orderly record of hours worked and pay. It’s your best backup in a wage dispute, which your policy may well not cover.
- Before a sensitive termination, talk to your attorney or your broker. It costs far less to do it before than after.
- If you receive a letter, an agency complaint or a threat of a lawsuit, notify your broker immediately. On a claims-made policy, timing matters.
A small team doesn’t make a business immune. What changes is that owners usually face these situations alone, with the business still running. Knowing the law applies from the first employee, and what the policy really covers, makes it possible to decide with more clarity and react in time.
At Rondon Brokerage, we’re here to help you understand risk and protect what matters most.


